Skip to main content

Doctors Should Do More to Encourage Flu Shots During Pregnancy: Study

July 09, 2014

By Ronnie Cohen

NEW YORK - Most doctors do not recommend flu shots to their pregnant patients, who are more likely to develop serious complications if they do get the flu, according to a new meta-analysis.

The researchers also found that pregnant women had concerns about the safety of the flu vaccine and tended to underestimate the risk that the virus posed to themselves and their fetus.

"The research is clear that healthcare providers are not providing advice to pregnant women about the importance and benefits of getting vaccinated," Marie Tarrant told Reuters Health in an email. She worked on the study at Li Ka Shing Faculty of Medicine at the University of Hong Kong.

"In addition, they are not making influenza vaccine available to their pregnant clients," she said. "By their silence, they are sending a message that influenza vaccine is actually not that important."

One study found pregnant women were five times as likely to be hospitalized with the flu as other women, Tarrant said.

The World Health Organization recently identified pregnant women as the highest priority group to receive seasonal flu vaccines. The U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention recommends the vaccines for women who are pregnant during flu season.

As reported online July 2 in Vaccine, Tarrant and her co-author Carol Yuet Sheung Yuen analyzed data from 45 studies including women from the U.S., Canada, Australia, Hong Kong, India, Turkey and various European countries. Most studies found that fewer than 60% of pregnant women received flu shots, and one showed vaccination rates below 2%.

A recommendation from a healthcare provider was one of the most consistent predictors of getting a flu shot, the researchers found. Women whose providers recommended flu shots were 20 to 100 times more likely to get vaccinated.

However, several studies found that providers offered negative advice about flu shots and in some cases, explicitly discouraged them.

The results were not surprising to Dr. Flor Munoz, a pediatrics and infectious disease researcher at Baylor College of Medicine in Houston, who was not involved in the current study.

"If doctors recommended the vaccine, people would take it," she told Reuters Health. "This paper is asking providers to be more vocal in recommending the vaccine to pregnant women."

The primary reason obstetricians cite for not advising pregnant women to get the vaccine, Munoz said, is that they do not stock it in their offices.

"They don't carry it," she said. "They see it as a burden, and they don't think it's worth it. For them to be able to get their return on investment is difficult, and that's why they don't do it."

The new review also found that pregnant women often worried about vaccine safety and side effects. One study found that 45% of pregnant women perceived the vaccine as unsafe and nearly 80% believed it could cause birth defects.

Some pregnant women were particularly concerned that mercury, present in certain flu vaccines, could harm their unborn children, the authors write.

Multi-dose vials of the flu vaccine contain small amounts of thimerosal, a mercury-containing preservative that prevents bacterial growth. Single-dose vaccine vials do not contain the preservative and are frequently available for pregnant women, Tarrant said.

"The amount of thimerosal in influenza vaccines is very small, and it has been shown repeatedly that it is not harmful," she said. "However, pregnant women may be more willing to accept the vaccine without thimerosal. So often that is provided."


Vaccine 2014.

(c) Copyright Thomson Reuters 2014. Click For Restrictions -

Back to Top